Last updated 10/12/14, 11/29/18
Two and a half years before Commodore Matthew C. Perry arrived, George Smith, the Anglican bishop of Hong Kong, dropped anchor at Naha, Okinawa. The date was 3 October 1850, and Perry wouldn’t arrive until 26 May 1853. Smith’s mission in Naha was to look into the welfare of Bernard Jean Bettelheim, a British subject, a medical doctor, and the contentious Protestant missionary who occupied the Gokoku-ji temple in Naha and remained on the island against the wishes of the Okinawan authorities.
Smith was unimpressed with the natives. “In both sexes,” he says, “there was a remarkable absence of everything associated in a European mind with the idea of beauty.” He describes a caste system in which the lowest are treated as slaves. Throughout, he claims that the Okinawans are essentially Japanese. He says, “Their features, partaking of a strong Mongolian cast and figure, are very different from the Chinese, and their great resemblance to the Japanese proves that the blood of the latter race predominates in their veins.”
Before Smith left, he received an “urgent petition” from “Ma-Leang-tsae (and others), the vice-governor-general of Lewchew, entreating his excellency to look down in compassion, and take away Bettelheim and his family to his home, that our little country may be at rest.”
The gist of the petition is strikingly familiar today, 160 years later. Bettelheim back then was the equivalent of American military bases today. The Okinawans want them out. They want to be free of forced relations.
Much of what was true then is true today. Okinawa is poor and hardly deserves being called a kingdom. Its primary occupation is subsistence, and it has little to offer other countries. Attempts to trade and interact with Okinawa place a tremendous burden on the kingdom’s limited resources.
The petition ends with a plea: “Look down in pity upon us; cease to send people to remain here; and desist from the attempt to trade with us and to teach us Christianity. Thus the whole country, government officers and people, will be thankful for ever.”
In 1854, the Okinawans were finally free of Bettelheim when Perry took him aboard his ship. In 2014, the Americans are entrenched even deeper in Okinawan soil, and the people are again urgently pleading for them to leave.
The excerpts below are from Smith’s account of his voyage, Lewchew and the Lewchewans; Being a Narrative of a Visit to Lewchew, or Loo Choo, in October, 1850 (London: T. Hatchard, 187, Piccadilly 1853).

Bishop George Smith
St. Paul’s College, Victoria, Hong Kong,
July, 1852.
At the present time Lewchew is the only avenue to Japan, the nearest part of which is only three hundred miles to the north-east. A mission to the former is in effect a mission prospectively to the latter country also. Present appearances indicate a probability that an unwonted effort will be made ere long by the United States to open Japan to foreign commerce. In such an event, a mission establishment at Lewchew would at once supply a body of linguists, already prepared and ready to enter upon this last remaining of the countries of the East at present debarred from intercourse with Christendom.
On Monday, September 23rd, 1850, I embarked at Hong Kong, in H.M. steam-sloop, the Reynard, which had been placed under orders by the naval commander-in-chief on the station, to convey me, on my first episcopal visitation, to the consular cities in the northern ports of China.
The wind changing to a fresh N.W. breeze, enabled us to run on in a direct course, and on October 3rd, we came in sight of the great Lewchew Island. A long chain of low coral islands stretches about twenty miles outside, and guards the approach from the south-west. We pursued our intricate course under steam, through the numerous islets and coral reefs, and came to anchor in the outer harbour of Napa, situated on the south-west extremity of the island. Continue reading →